Commentary DJ MCT-Op-Ed MENAFN News Saint Lucia

Commentary: St Lucia PM’s belated New Year’s address a torrent of half-truths, misrepresentations and outright lies: What world is he living in?

Commentary: Security challenges compound financial vulnerability in St Lucia
Melanius Alphonse is a administration and improvement marketing consultant, a long-standing senior correspondent and a contributing columnist to Caribbean Information Now. His areas of focus embrace political, financial and international safety developments, and on the newest information and opinion. His philanthropic pursuits embrace advocating for group improvement, social justice, financial freedom and equality. He contributes to particular programming on Radio Free Iyanola, RFI 102.1FM and Information Now International evaluation. He might be reached at [email protected]

By Melanius Alphonse

Saint Lucia Prime Minister Allen Chastanet’s belated New Yr’s tackle on January 13, 2019, was nothing greater than a torrent of half-truths, misrepresentations, and outright lies, however extra, maybe, was his extraordinary aloofness.

To enrich this, his tragic fevered creativeness doesn’t converse to the inherent dignity and worth for Saint Lucians as an entire, with a degree of genuine ardour worthy of celebrating and defending – besides, to say, “It’s Our Time” [Family, Friends, and Foreigners] “the type that listens to the considerations of our individuals and bona fide organizations.”

Fairly aside, days prior, junior minister with duty for tradition, Senator Fortuna Belrose, in contrast the federal government of Saint Lucia to the biblical chief Joshua, who led the youngsters of Israel into the Promised Land, saying, “This yr will probably be considered one of deliverance for Saint Lucians. So we might be proud that we’ve a authorities that listens to the heart beat of the individuals and is aware of the realities and is responding and main the best way.”

So, let’s unpack the “state of the nation” with out concern about being admonished that: “We should perceive that we don’t chew the hand that feeds us and anticipate every thing to be alright.”

Prime Minister Chastanet mumbled by means of a number of messaging clichés to explain 2019 stating, “It’s Our Time” – “give it as soon as once more function, vitality and course” including, “2019 would be the yr of implementation as a lot of private and non-private sector tasks get underway; translating into the most important infusion of capital into our financial system ever.”

Based on the prime minister, “The insurance policies of this authorities are to offer reasonably priced, high quality well being care, a globally aggressive schooling, and public security and safety for all. Our insurance policies are designed to create alternatives for our individuals by means of employment and participation in financial exercise.”

But when anybody continues to be in shock by the change that Prime Minister Chastanet is planning for Saint Lucia you then haven’t been taking note of precisely what meaning for nation and for everybody else, as he continues to mess up the state of the nation in stagnation.

Glistening Ineptitude

In underneath 25 minutes, the prime minister rearranged prior brash speak, and election guarantees and even probably the most controversial tasks, the Desert Star Holdings “Pearl of the Caribbean”, including, “We’re getting set to improve the Hewanorra Worldwide Airport to the tune of US$170 million.”

Reality: Extra elementary is that authorities has assured the Hewanorra Worldwide Airport (HIA) mortgage of US$100 million from the Export–Import Financial institution of the Republic of China (Taiwan) for the HIA Redevelopment Undertaking on behalf of the Saint Lucia Air & Sea Ports Authority (SLASPA) with little public info on specifics of the mortgage and improvement plans.

Arguably, mathematical formulation set the framework for public debate and resonate over authorities assure [US$100 or 170 million] and other people’s precise experiences now dwelling with the results of the fixation on double-digit progress at any value, versus individuals’swellbeing.

Reality: Reporting to parliament, December 11, 2018, Allen Chastanet, prime minister and minister for finance, stated: “With present borrowing [EC$1.5 billion] the debt to GDP ratio is predicted at 64.2 %. Unemployment fee is 20.9 %, and youth unemployment has elevated to 38 %, whereas inflation is at 2 %.”

Economists fear the debt-to-GDP ratio is at the very least 86 %, and public debt ratio, which was projected to succeed in 81.three % of GDP in 2023, already exists. There goes the necessity for an adjustment aimed toward attaining the ECCU debt goal of 60 % of GDP by 2030.

The quotation that: “My administration inherited the most important and quickest debt accumulation in 5 years at $three.1 billion. The very best recorded youth and general unemployment charges and the weakest financial system within the OECS,” and continuously blaming the Saint Lucia Labour Get together (SLP) for two-and-a-half years is attribute of a infantile chief, with no grownup in Cupboard and his administration succesful to tame waywardness.

The backlash the Chastanet administration is presently witnessing means that individuals are turning towards their defective understanding of individuals lives and the distorted three % financial progress that erroneously suggests the nation is doing nicely for everybody.

In like method, it isn’t lifelike that “It’s time that we come out of the mindset that every part that authorities does have to be topic to a political interpretation, [when in fact it is] or be seen as alternative to create mischief, confusion and division,” when the Chastanet led administration fails to take its personal recommendation to “put away the petty and foolish squabbles that continually appear to floor and which solely serve to foment division.”

There’s the adage, authorities units the tone for the nation. And whereas “nation constructing is a critical matter,” reviews recommend it’s an outright misinform say, “During the last 30 months our authorities has been capable of stabilize the financial system.”

Reality: The 5 to stay-a-live coverage continues to suck out at the very least EC$52 million yearly from the financial system whereas transferring wealth to the one % financial and political elites.

Nationwide Safety

The prime minister’s misrepresentations of the details reads: “The Labour Get together authorities’s irresponsible dealing with of the IMPACS investigation, has additionally contributed to the sharp decline within the morale of our police, who’re doing their utmost in overwhelming circumstances.”

Reality: Culpability is squarely with the federal government ministers within the earlier Stephenson King administration and police officers chargeable for Operation Restore Confidence (ORC) debacle within the first place.

Eleven felony suspects have been allegedly killed by the police throughout ORC however nobody liable for the killings has ever been prosecuted and, in truth, even inquests into the deaths additionally turned delayed.

Furthermore, the prime minister’s utterance isn’t overly useful within the midst of the current crime wave, to message: “Strategically, we’ve taken selections to strengthen our police pressure and justice system; nevertheless, we acknowledge we nonetheless have an extended approach to go in offering the fundamentals which are very important to critical crime preventing. However equally we can be asking for accountability.”

In different phrases, “The technique is to say that there’s a technique” and “to interact extra younger individuals to hitch golf equipment and never gangs,” whereas his administration withdrew after faculty packages and defund points of the social security internet, thereby compounding vulnerability.

Evidently there is a rise within the ranges of violence, and humiliation within the rule of regulation, to the purpose of nation shame, that the writ division, weak individuals unit, legal administration workplace and felony data workplace have been burglarized over the Christmas season.

In the meantime a complete answer nonetheless eludes authorities, and the Royal Saint Lucia Police Drive (RSLPF) sustained damaging penalties for public safety, ethical and civic values, and the longer term success of the nation’s financial system is detrimental.

In likeness to the Allen Chastanet administration, unfit for governance, persistent failures on the a part of the RSLPF illustrate that your complete senior management ought to have all submitted their resignation by now, if not changed forthwith.

Housing/Social Security Internet

The elimination of the misery fund within the 2017-18 finances for poor individuals in occasions of emergency, particularly home fires, seven households that have been destroyed by hearth on New Yr’s Day, nevertheless, the prime minister lacks compassion for common Saint Lucians and as an alternative presents fading hopes, fantasy goals and a photograph ops.

The place’s the cheque, in recognition to human struggling and compassion for common Saint Lucians? It’s the best factor to do!

Additional, the Nationwide Apprenticeship Programme (NAP) inside the Workplace of the Prime Minister, working as some sort of employment company propagates the servant grasp relationship, serves to depress wages.

In the meantime the prime minister’s answer is such that “Initially we had promised a $10 million injection;” nevertheless, noting that the SLDB has attracted a big variety of individuals wishing to personal a house and enhance their financial and social well-being, “we doubled that quantity to $20 million,” in a stagnant financial system.

The Schooling System

That is worse than one may think with the minister for schooling altering accents, whereas youngsters are stored out of faculty for weeks on finish.

Reality: “Beneath the EQUIP challenge we’ve invested $10 million within the enlargement, rehabilitation and furnishing of a number of studying establishments to enhance the standard, relevance and effectiveness of instruction within the schooling sector.” A continuation from the earlier authorities.


The healthcare disaster is of no significance to the prime minister prefaced on his non-committal to transition Victoria and St Jude hospitals.

His ethos is that of sporadic development of polyclinics, mini hospitals and sensible well being care amenities [FFF module] with no relationship to the first hospitals Owen King European Union (OKEU) and St Jude hospital.

“We’ve already commenced clearing works for the brand new hospital wing and the ministries of well being and financial improvement have finalized the design. Development is about to start out inside the subsequent few weeks.”

Notably, no point out of the standing of OKEU with personal overseas curiosity, which is seemingly corresponding to deception. Maybe, healthcare in Saint Lucia is regrettable, an à la carte menu of providers, coupled with a disjointed nationwide healthcare insurance coverage scheme.

Investments and Developments

The prime minister’s financial improvement is premised on wholesale privatization of presidency providers.

Desilting of the John Compton Dam, Grace and Dennery, spending roughly EC$168 million in 2019 within the water sector, whereas main tasks up north would be the regeneration of the capital, lags behind a complete improvement methods to buttress public spending with the appropriate policy-mix to stability public administration reforms, labour and commerce market flexibility, to strengthen the social networks and safety laws.

Additional to that, the dedicated to getting the enterprise surroundings in higher form to create extra and higher jobs, in each the formal and casual sector should enhance by approach the convenience of doing enterprise. Chopping general value and paperwork of doing enterprise would assist innovation, know-how, human and monetary capital unfastened to drive progress.

That is additional proof that “Each profitable metropolis has a strategic benefit or focus that permits it to be aggressive on a worldwide foundation,” Castries just isn’t absolutely outlined, past the idea of demolition of historic buildings and constructing a park — à la Central Park.


Whereas the prime minister might have missed the memo from Winfresh just lately that demand for Saint Lucian bananas within the UK is predicted to say no by roughly 60 % in 2019, he stated, “Banana exports are at their highest in a number of years.”

Reality: There goes the monetary yr 2018/19 allocation of expenditure that “Key investments in agriculture shall be EC$four.38 million beneath the Banana Productiveness Enchancment Undertaking and the EC$three.02 million underneath the Agriculture Transformation Programme.”

Agriculture just isn’t existent within the bigger financial image the nation’s financial system. The vulnerabilities of meals (worth stability) inflation and meals safety challenges require a sensible shift in commerce insurance policies, as an pressing precedence to local weather change adaptation and excessive climate occasions.

Tourism Vulnerability

Safety challenges, the worldwide financial system and the sudden results of local weather change compound vulnerability to Saint Lucia’s tourism and “unique lodges” which might be closely sponsored with withholding tax and large concessions, disadvantageous to different sectors of the financial system.

Reality: Amongst all this, members of the ill-defined cupboard play nicely to “shut up and fall in line” beneath the command of impromptu conferences and attendance at a cupboard assembly lately held at Sandals.

Nevertheless, the benefactors of “This surge in tourism has resulted in Saint Lucia regaining its place because the main tourism vacation spot within the OECS,” has not translated to the financial properly being of the individuals and to replenish subsidies sucked out of the financial system, into overseas financial institution accounts.

Even so “recording in 2017 the very best variety of arrivals” is a zero sum recreation and extremely questionable, in relation to attaining double-digit progress at any value, trickledown economics and the individuals’s wellbeing.

As minister for tourism in 2006, Allen Chastanet promised six lodges. Up to now, not one lodge development is credited to his experience, in distinction to the SLP being credited to all new lodges, renovated and enlargement properties.

The a lot talked about citizenship by funding tasks and authorities touristic improvement in the present day, is a depressing failure, even to seemingly appeal to Ponzi scheme buyers working in competing citizenship packages in one other Caribbean island.


Saint Lucia is in hassle with a cynical political ploy and ill-conceived enterprise, improvement and/or funding magnates.

Authorities fiscal burdens are weak to international monetary circumstances, amidst low tax income and a shrinking tax base. The encumbrance of exorbitant tax exemptions and fraud create bigger price range deficits and better public borrowing.

The prospects of a debt ceiling continues to be possible, given that a substantial portion of presidency income is used to make curiosity funds and repair money owed. And that authorities deficit is predicted to will increase as a share of GDP contributing to rising public debt. Additional, ought to borrowing value rise as anticipated, financing circumstances and capital outflows will tighten.

The added danger is the worldwide commerce and funding have softened amidst US commerce struggle with China, the US authorities shutdown influence on progress and monetary stability and concern concerning the what ifs ought to a recession hit looms giant.

These instabilities improve systemic disruptions on the financial system and on the similar time prolong distressed circumstances on shrinking economies like Saint Lucia.

Subsequently, strengthening debt administration, eliminating corruption and bureaucratic inefficiency, and the necessity to bolster transparency to revive financial dynamism is foremost of a robust authorities necessary precept, eludes the prime minister.


Prime Minister Chastanet’s belated tackle is hardly a quick monitor to deliverance, besides “it’s our time” for FFF.

Two directions come to thoughts. Nepocracy triumphs when benefit is discarded by politicians and that it’s futile making an attempt to hide that idiocracy is a warning not a plan; à la Donald Trump – when narratives painting outlandish ignorance, to socio-economic realities.

The Worldwide Financial Fund (IMF) warnings of a potential new monetary disaster underline the significance of fiscal consolidation and structural reforms.

Apparently, others issues as nicely escaped the prime minister’s handle reminiscent of preparedness for socio-economic turbulence, fostering long-term progress by way of fiscal buffers like constructing human capital and fostering inclusive progress.

These are worrisome. And, giving that literal voice to real-world considerations has grow to be an attenuated political and financial ploy for the prime minister who bears relationship to the 43 % that he claims — not the well-preserved.

Maybe, he ought to learn Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell feedback on the Financial Membership of Washington, earlier this month and the World Financial institution’s January 2019 International Financial Prospects reviews.