Comedy News SF & Fantasy

“Downsizing” Liberal Hollywood: How the Film’s Christian Message Undermines Arguments for National Health Care

Downsizing

Downsizing is a dystopic satire on American values that has an unsurprising and credible core involving a sick and impoverished underclass. It’s credible as a result of the USA is alone among the many superior industrial nations in failing to offer common well being care, preferring, because the statistics clearly present, the costliest and least environment friendly choice. The movie’s answer to that is the motion of the great Samaritan. Why this rings true for a lot of People is, I might argue, the results of an incessant cultural reinforcement of the thought of any sensible change being relating to as socialist and opposite to the thought of (American) individualism. These kooky Europeans and their social experiments! Communes. Bongo drums and cheesecloth shirts.

* * *

Downsizing is a large shock of a film that takes us locations the American mainstream media don’t typically care to go.

It’s a witty and provocative examination of the American dream writ small, the hope of a Hollywood way of life at Bollywood costs. On this sci-fi world, the method of miniaturizing individuals is created with a purpose to prolong the world’s assets. This inspiring ideology is transformed right into a capitalist enterprise on US soil that guarantees the struggling center courses the chance to increase their greenback shopping for energy. Common people with average means can stay in a mansion and spend their days taking tennis classes and deal with themselves to leisurely lunches and reasonably priced diamond jewellery. Paul Safranek (Matt Damon) is the unfulfilled physiotherapist who makes an attempt to start this lifetime of easy consumerism together with his spouse, Audrey (Kristen Wiig). When she bails after he alone has been miniaturized, his financial state of affairs turns into inadequate to take care of the “dream,” and he begins a downward social spiral. It seems that even in suburban paradise (Leisureland, New Mexico), somebody wants to wash the bogs.

Downsizing additionally shows, in essence, sure debilitating constructs shared by many socially acutely aware People that assist to elucidate why the Democratic get together and its supporters are so weak and weak within the face of the reactionary politics of the Republican social gathering. Why is there no nationwide well being care within the USA? Why achieve this few consider it attainable to vary the inequities of American society (or that there are such issues)? The solutions lie within the “liberal” story of Paul Safranek’s path to non-public enlightenment.

Three excellent lead performances by Matt Damon, Christoph Waltz, and Hong Chou present a secure base to a thoughtfully nuanced script by Alexander Payne and Jim Taylor. There’s a depth to the writing that displays the maturation of concepts over a number of years. I’m wondering if Taylor and Payne are conversant in Kurt Vonnegut’s Slapstick, which includes a plot gadget whereby the Chinese language make themselves a lot smaller in an effort to increase assets. This isn’t an accusation of plagiarism as Downsizing doesn’t current such a glib skeleton of an concept however supplies us with a doctoral thesis. And full disclosure right here. I did a small spin on it myself in a brief story a couple of years again: “Thomas Malthus and the Beanstalk.” This solely provides me higher respect for the event of the idea in Downsizing. The writers fret concerning the logistics of creating dwelling tissue smaller and have their topics bear elaborate preparations together with having all their tooth extracted and bodily hair shaved whereas artificial physique elements could make you “ineligible” (avoiding point out of the insurmountable drawback of the human skeleton). Socially conscious Norway is cited because the environmentally pleasant supply of the unique experiments and supplies an applicable geopolitical location for the idealism of the idea. Measures and portions are given, medical insurance coverage and federal tax credit score are remarked on, precise costs and valuations are recited: and we should always word these particulars as a result of timid cinematic worlds not often danger even the point out of the price of a cup of espresso. Between the charming retro-modern designs and low cost haircuts, there’s the palpable really feel of a world debated and argued over at nice size by completed creators and writers. Positive, we will problem the specifics in a number of situations – and finally that is science fantasy trying to inform a significant story, not science fiction trying to construct an actual robotic – however give these guys some credit score for his or her efforts to make the capsule smoother.

Paul, performed by Matt Damon, is a uninteresting and humble everyman. Damon portrays him with a delicate physicality, as a sluggish, pudgy, and ever-so-slightly stooped determine, seemingly puzzled on the avarice or dishonesty of others. He’s not a reader or a thinker, and his broken ego is hammered house by his temporary courting of the dowdy Kristen (Kerry Kenni-Silver). As he descends the rungs of the financial ladder, his “downsizing” turns into inversely proportional to his religious power as a struggling and self-sacrificing particular person. It has a Christian message of goodness. This can be a Francis of Assisi parable the place Paul’s innate the Aristocracy turns into saintly by the brutality of circumstance. “Let me take all the load,” Paul says to his spouse in an early home scene, for that is his assigned position as caregiver to these in want.

After a drug-induced transformative get together expertise on the condo of Dusan (Christoph Waltz), an enthralling contraband smuggler with a coronary heart of gold, silver, and copper, he meets the one-legged Ngoc Lan Tran (Hong Chau). Ngoc is a bossy civil rights campaigner from Vietnam, a sufferer of her authorities’s underhanded strategies to take away dissidents by shrinking them and handing them off to slavers who present low cost labor for the rich West. Via Ngoc, Paul is launched to the underbelly of Leisureland, the barrio on the opposite aspect of an enormous wall. Right here immigrants live in close to destitution subsequent to a society that hardly admits their existence, in prison-like tenements, the place, in an oddly efficient scene, they’re lulled of their quotidian lives by communal screenings of Bonanza in Spanish.

After Paul by chance breaks Ngoc’s prosthetic leg, he agrees to do her housecleaning work in addition to her group help, serving to the sick and choosing up free meals from round city to offer to these struggling to outlive within the tenement. Dusan is initially amused by Paul’s willingness for abasement however does supply him a means out with a visit to Norway and the chance to satisfy the originals of the experiment. That is extra of a plot ploy to get our three major characters to the Norwegian group as Ngoc goes as nicely, saying that she has an impressive invitation from the primary scientist behind downsizing, Dr. Jørgen Asbjørnsen (Swedish actor Rolf Holger Lassgård).

Downsizing

The fjord scenes are a welcome respite for the viewers at this level from Paul’s social descent. He will get to be completely happy for a short while in a overseas land with pleasant individuals. Too dangerous the world goes to finish. Asbjørnsen’s spouse explains one thing about “a methane launch in Antarctica” meaning the annihilation of the human race. On the plus aspect, Paul and Ngoc cement their relationship in an enthralling method on the tiny ferryboat because it makes its approach up the nonetheless waters of the fjord at night time.

The settlement seems like an idyllic lilliputian commune (from c. 1972), with small picket homes with sod roofs, horse-drawn buggies, and bongo drums. It’s inhabited solely by people with beneficiant hearts and amiable natures, although one or two are just a little crazy. Right here Paul is knowledgeable that the group is planning to go underground in a specifically constructed self-sustainable cavern for eight thousand years to flee annihilation. He’s invited to hitch them. ‘I lastly have an opportunity to do one thing that issues,” Paul causes. Ngoc gained’t go as a result of she has her obligations again within the US. Dusan gained’t as a result of he doesn’t consider the destruction of humanity is imminent and thinks the group members are more likely to go loopy underground. Paul decides to return with Ngoc, and the final scene has him offering meals to a needy neighbor and pausing to look again at an in any other case doleful scene and smile, maybe in satisfaction at discovering a function to his life.

Downsizing

So why does all this recommend that progressive politics in America are doomed?

It’s clear the creators didn’t need a Capra film the place the system collapses when confronted with the ire of a single good man. Nor did they need us to wallow in despair. That is neither a Mr. Smith Goes to Washington nor a Brazil. That is an attraction to the beatitudes. Blessed are the poor. Blessed are the meek. They current no different answer. Paul finds his place on the earth by laboring every day between the cracks of society to maintain what the system fails to do. How successfully might an argument for well being look after all match into this cinematic framework?

Ngoc is a Christian. One episode has her dragging Paul to a quaintly ethnic service the place she prays in absent-minded rapture. Eighty-five % of Vietnamese are Buddhist and fewer than 7 % Christian. Why not make her what she is twelve occasions extra more likely to be? A Buddhist. Sure, a broader American viewers will get to understand her actions in a approach they will determine with as churchgoers. Sadly, it aids the persistence of a assemble of goodness and social duty being the only area of Christianity, the font of all that’s ethical and moral in accordance with many Westerners. Then again, there isn’t any faith related to the Norwegians. Dusan truly accuses them of being “a cult!” On this parable of consumerism versus social duty, is northern European social democracy being represented as a cult? That’s in all probability going a bit too far, however the connection has been made. What we’re left with is just not a name for society to vary however for people to only be good to at least one one other. An updating of American individualism to accommodate saintly abstinence and good deeds.

Downsizing

Downsizing is a dystopic satire on American values that has an unsurprising and credible core involving a sick and impoverished underclass. It’s credible as a result of the USA is alone among the many superior industrial nations in failing to offer common well being care, preferring, because the statistics clearly present, the costliest and least environment friendly choice. The movie’s answer to that is the motion of the great Samaritan. Why this rings true for a lot of People is, I might argue, the results of an incessant cultural reinforcement of the thought of any sensible change being relating to as socialist and opposite to the thought of (American) individualism. These kooky Europeans and their social experiments! Communes. Bongo drums and cheesecloth shirts. As Dusan intimates, these issues crumble they usually find yourself killing one another. Capitalism is the pure order. Injustice is inevitable. Even in what some may see as a liberal Hollywood movie, the politics are reactionary and a reinforcement of the established order. There’s little room to see America because the odd one out, the results of a geographically marooned superpower with first a century of slavery after which a century of apartheid shaping a systemic disdain for its decrease class.

Downsizing

In fact, the one social positions offering common well being care on this nation are within the army. Rumor has it the armed forces usually are not usually favorable to leftist considering, however this health-care enterprise makes them seem like a bunch of commies. Or does it? The historical past of nationwide well being care is tied to conservative nations with a robust army, the primary occurring in Germany within the 1880s. The event of the British NHS required arguments from each side of the aisle. David Lloyd George, the Liberal Prime Minister (1916-22), is famously quoted as saying “The white man’s burden needed to be carried on robust backs.”

Whereas there are a flurry of articles suggesting “socialism” is “not a unclean phrase anymore,” I feel it far too early to anticipate a sea change on this nation’s thought patterns.. Communism was the bogeyman. On this period it’s socialism. And the political proper and center floor have achieved such a exceptional job of tainting the time period with adverse connotations that many individuals react identical to “poor” Meghan McCain and say, “It’s petrifying to me that [socialism] is being normalised! A few of us don’t need socialism normalized on this nation.” The Democratic Socialists of America might crow about having 47,000 members now, however 1 / 4 of the American inhabitants contemplate themselves Evangelicals. And if that isn’t dangerous sufficient, we’ve two respectable and educated males like Jim Taylor and Alexander Payne reminding us so cleverly of the futility of supposed socialist aspirations. Go it alone, they appear to inform us, like St. Francis, like Mom Theresa, like Paul on the street to Leisureland.

I’ve little question that Downsizing will turn into extra well-liked as time goes on. It’s an clever and splendidly carried out movie. My solely remorse is that it does nothing to change the entrenched biases of a center class nonetheless traumatized by the political values of the 1950s.

* * *

All photographs courtesy of Paramount Footage.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email