Letters News St Vincent and the Grenadines

Letter: Modern day Lotus-eaters – Caribbean News Now

Letter: Modern day Lotus-eaters - Caribbean News Now

Pricey Sir:

Whereas searching just lately I used to be not in any means stunned to find that St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG) in the course of the yr 2017 was ranked because the third poorest nation within the Caribbean, under Haiti, then listed because the poorest.

Nevertheless, whereas studying via a few works just lately I started to ponder the prevailing plight of a few of us Vincentians, stranded right here on these small items of lands, poverty stricken and begging our method the world over. These works have been, specifically, Africa — Africans as Seen by Classical Writers, by William Leo Hansberry, and the equally fascinating The African Origin of Civilization, Fable or Actuality by Cheikh Anta Diop. These books are nicely value studying for many who are concerned about origins.

Such works encourage one to ponder the march of historical past. They likewise evoke ideas of what had been the rise and fall of some nations, the delivery and progress of human civilizations. Noting the interactions of peoples. The very unhappy end result for some, when governments fail their individuals. Certainly, in current occasions we noticed the rise and fall of the Soviet system and the way it failed the individuals there too.

In the course of the previous Sunday we have been studying that an ex-Supreme Courtroom decide from Venezuela Mr Christian Zerpa, had legged it to the US. There he denounces Nicolás Maduro and says that Venezuela’s Supreme Courtroom is ‘an appendage’ of Nicolás Maduro’s authorities. However does that assertion of his in any approach shock us? Not one bit!

It’s reported that this one-time Nicolás Maduro backer, Mr Justice Christian Zerpa advised a Miami broadcaster on Sunday sixth January 2019 that Nicolás Maduro doesn’t “deserve” to serve a second six-year time period in workplace. Lots of his fellow nation man would most definitely agree with him and have expressed their views by vacating the nation too identical to him, and have legged it as quick as they will to the closest border crossing that they might discover.

“I’ve determined to go away Venezuela to disavow the federal government of Nicolás Maduro,” Mr Zerpa stated in an interview with the Miami based mostly EVTV reporter. He went on, “I consider President Nicolás Maduro doesn’t deserve a second probability as a result of the election he supposedly gained was not free and aggressive.” Shock shock!

Might there be any parallel right here with us in St Vincent and the Grenadines, in any case, Ralph Gonsalves, the prime minister right here, is certainly an avid supporter and really shut ally of the Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and Ralph Gonsalves too has been accused by the opposition right here of stealing the 2015 St Vincent and the Grenadines election right here likewise.

Nevertheless, the primary opposition Nationwide Democratic Social gathering right here has been bedevilling to get the matter resolved in our regulation courts. However whereas there’s a lot worldwide opposition to the Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro’s rule, Ralph Gonsalves has had an easy time of it, as he, Ralph Gonsalves, being a lawyer, has proved himself fairly adept at prolonging the matter by means of our courtroom system.

The defection of Mr Justice Christian Zerpa comes amid a lot rising worldwide strain on President Nicolas Maduro over his new time period of workplace, which he supposedly gained in a extensively boycotted 2018 election. That election was dismissed by many nations as an entire sham.

Certainly, there are various right here in SVG who’re questioning a system like ours, which permits for a state of affairs reminiscent of has occurred right here, the place the result of the overall election has been vigorously challenged however a decision inside the courtroom system might be so annoyed by one of many events, and a decision so lengthy in coming, it makes nonsense of the complete problem itself, reputable or in any other case.

It’s the customized of all ruling dictators to so corrupt administrative and civic establishments inside any given nation that eradicating them from workplace turns into close to unattainable. Such establishments are more likely to embrace the civil service, the courtroom system, the police service and all different civil/civic bureaucracies, so as to cement and delay their fairly often autocratic dictatorial rule. A parliamentary type of authorities corresponding to ours has not in any means proved to be a hindrance to such an end result.

Certainly, returning to Zerpa, for years, Mr Christian Zerpa was an in depth ally of Nicolás Maduro whereas sitting on the Supreme Courtroom. The stated Supreme Courtroom that had backed Nicolás Maduro’s ruling Socialist Social gathering in each main authorized dispute since Nicolás Maduro’s election in 2013. But we see how fortunes have modified there with so many former backers abandoning the regime.

Mr Christian Zerpa had certainly written a 2016 ruling that offered the authorized justification for the Maduro authorities to strip Venezuela’s Nationwide Meeting of most of its powers, after the opposition had gained management of that physique within the then landslide election. However because the Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro cements his nefarious controls over all issues Venezuelan, so life underneath his dictatorship turns into most insufferable, as inflation spirals uncontrolled and people individuals who can leg it, simply merely run away.

However what’s the view from St Vincent and the Grenadines? Some right here see themselves little higher off. We’ve a captive authorities dominated over by a budding dynastic household, the Gonsalves household. The household has reneged on their chief Ralph Gonsalves’ 1999 electioneering promise to allow us to have a “Freedom of Info Parliamentary Invoice” and has promoted a lot nepotism and cronyism right here.

Our Parliament has proved itself to be nothing however a rubber stamp for the Gonsalves household’s curiosity and, identical to the Venezuelans, our civil and civic establishments are so corrupted that they’re greatest prevented at the most effective of occasions — that’s if one can.

Our begging technique have introduced in some a lot wanted income, in contrast to the Venezuelans who’ve refused all overseas assist and have been our foreign money not beneath the auspices of the Japanese Caribbean Central Financial institution, the ECCB, and the occasional go to from the IMF, we might little question be experiencing the identical hyperinflation right here, identical to the Venezuelans. Excessive taxation has destroyed companies with little incentive for people to determine new ones.

Have been we to start out operating from right here, we neither have the best way with all of it nor wealthy neighbours who might obtain us. Our worrying query is that this, if and when push ultimately involves shove right here, would our supreme courtroom be of any use to us. For we positive have been left excessive and dry up to now for close to on 18 years and most definitely after the final election. With issues as it’s right here thus far, we’re positively up the Suwannee and undeniably with out a lot as a paddle. The Caribbean elite have seen to that.

Mr Christian Zerpa, in his interview with the Miami based mostly EVTV reporter on Sunday described the Venezuelan Supreme Courtroom as an “appendage of the chief department” of Nicolás Maduro’s authorities and stated that his fellow justices have been typically summoned to the presidential palace to obtain their directions on the best way to rule on sure delicate instances.

Zerpa went on to say that he didn’t leg it out from Venezuela earlier nor come out publicly towards Nicolás Maduro’s re-election final Might as a result of he needed to make sure that each he and his household might depart the nation fairly safely. One can’t fault him in such a shrewd and clever transfer. A stint in certainly one of Nicolás Maduro’s prisons wouldn’t have been good for his well being.

For positive, Mr Christian Zerpa’s hanging phrases have echoed these of like former Justice Eladio Aponte, who fled to the US in 2012 and stated the federal government of Venezuela’s lifeless socialist chief Hugo Chavez — Maduro’s predecessor — had systematically manipulated courtroom affairs. A recognized basic motion on the a part of all dictators. From Joseph Stalin, the Soviet dictator, to Saddam Hussein Abd al-Majid al-Tikriti, former president of Iraq.

Elections are usually not the excessive level in dictatorships. Common elections have been held right here in St Vincent and the Grenadines on 9 December 2015. That’s some three years in the past and extra now, but Vincentians have by no means been very positive as to who ought to be their reputable authorities as a result of our personal ruling household’s shenanigans. Just like the Venezuelan chief they’ve annoyed our figuring out.

An extra query to be requested of ourselves is, how on earth we as a individuals got here to this? Why have we been so badly trodden down that we, just like the Venezuelans, discover ourselves hostage to a system that works just for an elite and never for almost all?

We who boast of getting a parliament, the offspring of “the Mom of all Parliaments” in Westminster, but we’re so miserably handled with so little protest from us!

I’m reminded of Homer’s Odyssey and the “lotus-eaters”. Have we have now been lowered to mere “lotus-eaters”? We positive have left off caring and are simply fetching our consuming water in reed baskets, whereas the “Papa” begs around the globe.

The day’s gleeful announcement is that we’ve acquired new EU/British help to restore our roads, subsequent will come once more the British to construct a brand new port, the Japanese to construct a fish facility to be intently adopted by the Taiwanese with a digital camera system, on the heels of the Indian authorities with a brand new business constructing. USAid and lots of others to comply with quickly.

As a reminder of issues to return. Not so way back the Japanese had constructed us a fantastic complicated in Kingstown, regionally referred to as “Little Tokyo” however sadly now solely the rats are presently its contented residents, because it has fallen into complete dilapidation and gross disrepair by means of neglect. Even our Parliament constructing has shrubs rising out of it.

In Homer’s Odyssey we study this: “I despatched two of my firm to see what method of males the individuals of the place is perhaps, they usually had a 3rd man underneath them.

“They began directly, and went about among the many Lotus-eaters, who did them no harm, however gave them to eat of the lotus, which was so scrumptious that those that ate of it left off caring about residence, and didn’t even need to return and say what had occurred to them, however have been for staying and munching lotus with the Lotus-eaters with out considering additional of their return; however, although they wept bitterly I pressured them again to the ships and made them quick beneath the benches.

“Then I informed the remaining to go on board directly, lest any of them ought to style of the lotus and depart off eager to get residence, in order that they took their locations and smote the gray sea with their oars.”

However who will pressure us away from being modern-day Lotus-eaters?

James H